Editors Blog

How I Got Hooked on 'Twilight'

One woman's uneasy confession about the teen vampire novel that's about to become a blockbuster movie, by SPIN's Phoebe Reilly.
Twilight Cast
Twilight Cast

So I might have read Twilight.

Okay, I couldn't put it down and I'm not exactly sure why because the writing is atrocious. I could find excuses -- I was sick last weekend, I regretted having prematurely scoffed at Harry Potter -- but something about this book is appealing even when it shouldn't be.


Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen

It's essentially the story of a dangerously co-dependent relationship: Edward, a vampire, and Bella, the only human whose mind he can't read, are obsessed with one another and spend literally all their time together. He even watches her when she sleeps, which would normally be grounds for a cautionary After School Special, but in this case, it's excusable because Bella is constantly imperiled and Edward needs to save her.

Pure wish fulfillment: What could be better to a smitten teenager -- well, technically Edward is about 100 years old but we won't split hairs -- than to have a legitimate reason to always hang out with the person they're dating? Of course, they can't really do all that much because Edward might get aroused and devour her, which results in a sexual tension that is so toe-curling it's hard to believe that a Mormon mom with three young sons wrote it. As a fantasy, it works even if the reality is extremely unhealthy.

Anyway, a week ago, I knew very little about this book other than that it had provoked a total frenzy (and not just from 15-year-old girls, if the people who saw me reading it in public and stopped to tell me how great it was are any indication). Now I'm hooked. I've watched the trailer countless times and developed several strong opinions.

For one, Catherine Hardwicke is the ideal director. Based on her previous films (Thirteen, Lords of Dogtown), it's obvious that she considers herself to be "down" with teenagers and will probably bring some hipness to the characters (in the book, it doesn't seem like anyone's even heard of an iPod).


Pattinson and Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan

Kristen Stewart makes a better Bella than the original; she seems self-possessed whereas the character in the book is kind of cranky and petulant. But Nikki Reed as the unattainably gorgeous Rosalie Cullen? I don't see it. And Sisters of Mercy would have been a nice addition to the soundtrack, which instead features Paramore and Linkin Park.

As far as depictions of humane vampires go, this is no Buffy. But it's way better than True Blood. Personally, though, I miss the type of vampire who would to lure you into a cave, trick you into drinking "wine," and expect you to fly around listening to cheesy goth music while terrorizing a sleepy beach town.

Comments

Ann

Welcome to the Twilight fandom lol. I feel embarassed for liking these horribly written books, but I swear the pages are laced with crack! I disagree that Kristen Stewart is a good Bella, her acting seems pretty flat to me, if the trailer gives any indication of her abilities. And the soundtrack seems pretty lame in my opinion, they could have put some really cool tracks in there, but I guess they've got to appeal to all the screaming 13 year old fangirls.

maddie

Ah, yes. Twilight. My boss at the tea shop I work at named our only white tea "velvet dream" because it reminds her of Edward.
As an English major, I kind of have to pretend I don't like these books around my friends or else risk being mocked mercilessly for weeks. I really don't like them. The writing IS terrible. But once you start reading, it's hard to stop.

Got something to say?

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

Are You Human?
If so, enter the four-letter code below to post your comment.
Image CAPTCHA